What questions should I ask a video editing agency on the first call?
On the first call, ask who actually watches your footage, how quickly the first cut comes back, what a revision costs, what the per-episode price is once clips are included, and what kind of work they would turn down. A good agency answers all of that in plain numbers without needing to go away and check. I am on a lot of these calls myself, right, and I can usually tell early on whether someone has really thought about their show, so this page is basically the list I would bring if I was sitting on your side, along with the answers I would want to hear back and the ones that should make you pause.
Starter per episode: single camera, 1080p, 48-hour turnaround, 1 free revision
Studio per episode: two to four cameras, 4K, unlimited free revisions
Price for episodes up to 90 minutes, which is why you ask about length early
Podcast episodes released every month across the shows we work on
Who will actually edit my show, and does that stay the same each week?
I would open with this one, right, because it tells you how the agency is really built. Some agencies are one person with a few freelancers they pass work to when it gets busy, and some are proper teams, and neither is automatically wrong, but you should know which one you are buying from, because it changes what happens the week your editor is ill or away.
So ask who edits the episode, whether the same people stay on your show from week to week, and who covers when they are not around. For context, we are a team of close to 50 people working in-house from Dubai, and across the shows we work on, 200+ podcast episodes are released every month, so with us the more useful thing to push on is how your show's style stays consistent, and that is a completely fair question to ask.
If you want to think through what size of team actually makes sense for a weekly show, I wrote about it in how big a video editing team should be. The answer you want to hear on the call is a specific one, with roles or names, not just 'our team handles it'.
What exactly is included in the per-episode price?
Ask them to walk you through it line by line, right, because 'editing' means very different things at different places. You want to know whether it is a full listen-through or a silence-detection pass, how many cameras are included and at what resolution, whether colour is balanced across angles, whether audio levelling and noise cleanup are part of it, whether music is licensed, and what the length cap is before the price changes.
To give you an example of the kind of answer you should expect, our Starter plan is $199 per episode for a single camera, 1080p, a full listen-through edit by a human, intro, outro and sponsor reads, audio levelling and noise cleanup, 48-hour turnaround and 1 free revision, for episodes up to 60 minutes. Studio is $299 for two to four cameras synced and cut, 4K, colour balancing, lower thirds and custom graphics, premium music and sound effects, and unlimited free revisions. I laid all of it out in our pricing explained.
The catch here is the extras. Clips, show notes and rush delivery are where a low headline price can quietly turn into a high monthly bill, so ask what each of them costs before the call ends.
What happens to the price if my episode runs long or I add a camera?
This is the question people forget, and then they get a surprise invoice the first time a guest talks for an extra half hour, right. So ask how the price moves with length and with extra cameras, and ask for the answer in writing so nobody has to remember it later.
On our side it works like this. Episodes up to 30 minutes cost 0.75x of the plan price, episodes up to 90 minutes cost 1.3x, and anything longer than that, or extra camera angles beyond what the plan covers, we quote on a call before we start, so you know the number before the edit happens rather than after. A 4-episode pack saves 15% and a monthly plan saves 25%, and those are worth asking about too, because some agencies only discount when you sign something long.
The answer you want from any agency is a clear rule, not 'it depends' with nothing after it. If they cannot tell you what a 90 minute episode costs, I'm pretty sure you will find out the hard way at some point, and at the end of the day a pricing rule you understand is worth more than a slightly lower number you do not.
When does the turnaround clock start, and how do files get to you?
A turnaround number only means something once you know when the clock starts, right. Some agencies count from when they open the files, some from when they confirm the brief, and some count working days only, so a short turnaround on paper can quietly stretch into a week or more once you add it all up.
With us the clock starts when we receive your files, the first cut comes back within 48 hours, and revisions come back the next working day. If an episode is very long, has heavy graphics or four cameras, it can take a day longer and we tell you up front. For comparison, the category norm is 5 to 10 working days, which can be fine if you record well ahead, so the question is really whether their number fits your release day.
Also ask how files are sent, whether that is a Riverside link, Google Drive or Dropbox, and what time zone the team works in. Dubai is UTC+4, so an evening upload in the US is on an editor's desk at the start of our working day, and I explained how that works for American shows in overnight editing for US creators.
What will you need from me every week?
This one sounds like a small question, but it tells you whether the agency has a real process or is making it up as it goes, right. A good team will tell you exactly what they need per episode, for instance the raw files, the sponsor read wording, guest names spelled correctly, any moments you want kept or cut, and the date it goes live, and they will tell you how they like feedback to arrive.
If the answer is basically 'just send us the files and we will figure it out', that sounds easy, but it usually means the first few episodes are guesswork and you end up doing all the correcting in revisions. I would rather an agency asks me for a little more up front and gets it right, than asks for nothing and needs several rounds of notes to get there.
So ask how revisions work as well. Our Starter plan includes 1 free revision and Studio includes unlimited free revisions, both coming back the next working day, and the way you give notes, with timestamps and everything in one message, makes a bigger difference to speed than most people expect. The less back and forth there is, the more your weekly rhythm holds.
Have you grown anything of your own?
I like this question a lot, and I think more people should ask it, right, because editing for growth is a different skill from editing cleanly. A clean edit removes mistakes, and a growth edit makes decisions about the opening seconds, which moments become clips, where attention drops and what to cut so that it does not.
The way to test it is to ask what they have built for themselves. In our case we run seven YouTube channels of our own, each past 100,000 subscribers, grown by us, and we make revenue from social media ourselves, so when we suggest a hook or a clip it comes from watching our own numbers week after week. An agency without anything of its own can still be very good at clean editing, and if that is all you need, that is fine, but you should know which one you are paying for.
If you are not sure how much growth thinking you need from an editor, I went through it in whether your editor should understand YouTube growth. You see what I mean here, the question is really about what kind of editor you are hiring, not just whether they can cut.
What would make you the wrong agency for me?
If I could only ask one question, it would be this one, right, because an honest agency answers it quickly and a desperate one struggles. So let me be very honest with our own answer. If you need someone physically in the room on shoot day, a studio to record in, or a one-off cinematic brand film with a crew and a big production budget, we are not the right fit, and a local US editor, a podcast studio or a production company will do that job better.
What we are built for is remote editing of shows that publish regularly, so the weekly podcast, the YouTube interview series, the clips and show notes that come off them, and full done-for-you management if you want publishing and posting handled too, with a podcast manager as one point of contact, which we quote on a call.
If an agency cannot name a single kind of project it would turn away, that is worth noting, and I listed a few more of those warning signs on the red flags page. At the end of the day the first call is you interviewing them, so bring the list and ask every question on it. So yeah. That's my way of saying it.
Bring these questions to the first call
- Who watches my episode from start to finish, and is it the same people each week?
- What is included in the per-episode price, and what costs extra on top?
- How does the price change for a shorter or longer episode, or another camera?
- When does the turnaround clock start, and on what day will I see the first cut?
- How many revisions are included, and how quickly do they come back?
- What have you grown for yourselves that I can go and look at?
- What kind of client or project would you turn down?
Frequently asked questions
What is the most important question to ask a video editing agency?
Ask what would make them the wrong fit for you. An honest agency answers quickly and specifically, for instance that it does not record in a studio or shoot on location. If they cannot name anything they would turn down, they will probably say yes to work they are not set up for, and you find out after you have paid.
Should I ask for a test episode before committing to a plan?
Starting with a single episode before any pack or monthly plan is completely reasonable. Paying for one episode lets you judge the edit, the turnaround and how revisions are handled. With us that is Starter at $199 or Studio at $299, and you can move onto a 4-episode pack or a monthly plan once you are happy with the work.
What should I have ready before the first call?
Have a link to a recent episode, your typical episode length, how many cameras you record with, which platforms you publish on, how often you release, and a rough budget. With those in hand, an agency can give you a real price on the call, including any length adjustment, instead of promising to follow up with a quote later.
Is it fine to ask where the team is based?
It is, and you should, because location tells you about time zones, working hours and cost. We are close to 50 people working in-house from Dubai, which is UTC+4 and 8 to 12 hours ahead of the continental US, so an evening upload from the US is on an editor's desk at the start of our working day.
What answers on a first call should make me walk away?
Walk away if nobody can say who watches your footage, if turnaround is described as soon, if there is no price anchor even for a simple episode, or if they push a long contract before you have seen an edit. Any one of those is worth a follow-up question, and several together usually mean the fit is wrong.
Keep reading
Ready to stop editing your own podcast?
Bring this list to a call with us and ask every question on it, or check our pricing first if you want the numbers before we talk.