The mistakes beginners make in their first 20 podcast episodes
The most common mistakes in the first 20 podcast episodes are starting with no clear listener in mind, slow intros that lose people in the first minute, poor audio, changing the format and schedule too often, weak titles with no clips, and judging the show far too early. Almost all of them are fixable, and most come from treating the episode as the finished product instead of the start of the work. I see this from both sides, right, because we edit for shows releasing 200+ episodes a month and we also run seven YouTube channels of our own, so I watch first episodes up close all the time, and episode 20 can look nothing like episode one if you fix these on purpose.
YouTube channels we run ourselves, each grown by us past 100,000 subscribers
Podcast episodes released every month across the shows we work on
Per vertical clip as an add-on, captioned and cut 9:16 from the same footage
Starter plan per episode, single camera, full human edit and a 48-hour turnaround
Why does a vague show idea start hurting you by episode five?
The first mistake usually happens before episode one, right, and it is starting a show about something broad like business, health or life in general without deciding who exactly is listening. For the first two or three episodes you do not notice, because you have plenty of ideas, but by episode five or six you are picking topics at random, inviting guests because they said yes rather than because your listener needs them, and writing titles that could belong to any show on the platform. A new listener lands on the page, cannot tell in a few seconds whether this is for them, and moves on.
The fix is one sentence you can say out loud, for instance a show for first-time founders of service businesses about landing their first ten clients, and every topic, guest and title gets checked against that sentence before it goes in the calendar. It feels limiting at first, but a narrow show is so much easier to grow, because the right people recognise themselves in it straight away and they tell others like them. If you are still deciding between interview, solo or co-hosted, I compared them in choosing a podcast format.
Why do listeners leave in the first minute of a new podcast?
Almost every beginner show opens the same way, right, with a long music intro, then welcome back to the show, then how was your week, then some housekeeping and maybe a sponsor read, and only after a few minutes does the real conversation begin. On our own YouTube channels the first moments of a video decide a lot about whether someone stays, and video podcasts on YouTube and Spotify behave the same way, so a slow start quietly costs you listeners on every episode, the good ones included.
What works much better is opening on the strongest twenty or thirty seconds of the conversation, a sharp opinion, a story or the answer to the question in the title, then a very short intro that says who you are and what this episode is about, and then straight into the content. You can record naturally and let the editor pull that cold open from the middle later, which is basically what we do on a lot of the shows we edit. Keep the small talk if you enjoy it, just move it out of the opening, because the first minute is the one place where nobody owes you their attention yet, you see what I mean here.
How much does audio quality matter in the first episodes?
People will forgive a lot in an early show, average lighting, a plain background, a few nervous moments and so on, but they will not forgive audio that is hard to listen to, and that is the part beginners underestimate, right. The usual culprits are a laptop mic, a bare room with hard walls that makes everything echo, two people sharing one mic, one voice far louder than the other, and a remote guest on earbuds from a cafe. Each of these makes the listener work harder, and most people simply leave rather than work.
You do not need an expensive studio to fix it. A decent dynamic USB mic for each speaker, headphones so nobody's audio bleeds into the other mic, a room with a rug, curtains or a sofa to soak up the echo, and separate tracks for every person will get you most of the way, and the editor can then level the voices and clean the background noise far more easily. If you are recording video too, put the light in front of you rather than behind, keep the camera at eye level and check the framing before you start. Good habits on episode three save you hours of cleanup on episode thirty.
Why is changing the format every few episodes a mistake?
This one comes from good intentions, right, because beginners notice what is not working and want to fix it straight away, so episode four is an interview, episode seven goes solo, episode nine adds a co-host, the release day moves from Monday to Thursday, the name changes, the intro music changes, and by episode twelve the show feels like three different podcasts stitched together. Listeners build a habit around a show, a day, a length and a feel, and every time that shifts you are basically asking them to start the habit again from zero.
My honest suggestion is to commit to one format, one rough length and one release day for your first 20 episodes, and write the things you want to change in a list instead of changing them on the spot. At episode 20 you look at the list, pick the one or two changes that matter most and make them together, so the show evolves in clear steps rather than constant small wobbles. Pick a schedule you can actually hold, because a steady show every two weeks beats a weekly one that skips three weeks in a row, and I go through the trade-offs in how often you should release podcast episodes.
Why do titles like 'Episode 12 with [guest name]' hold a show back?
Beginner shows almost always title episodes by number and guest name, right, and the catch here is that nobody searches for an episode number, and unless your guest is already well known, nobody searches for their name either. A title has one job, which is to tell a stranger scrolling past what they will get from the next hour, so a title built around the problem, the idea or the surprising claim in the conversation will do far more work than a label. The same goes for thumbnails, where a busy screenshot of two people on a video call just disappears on a phone screen.
The other half of packaging that beginners skip is clips. A full episode is a big ask for someone who has never heard of you, but a short captioned vertical clip on Instagram, TikTok or LinkedIn is an easy yes, and it is often how new people find the show at all. So for every episode, write the title before you publish and ask whether a stranger would click it, make a thumbnail with a face and a few large words, and cut three or four clips from the best moments. I go deeper on this in podcast titles and thumbnails that get clicks.
Why do beginners judge their podcast too early?
I'm pretty sure this is the mistake that ends the most shows, right, and it looks like checking downloads every morning from episode one, comparing your numbers to shows that have been running for years, and deciding around episode eight that it is not working. Early numbers move slowly for almost every new podcast and they tell you very little at that stage, so when you judge the show on them you end up quitting just before the habits you built start paying off.
A better way is to launch properly, with two or three episodes live on day one so a new listener has something to binge, and then set two review points, one at episode 10 and one at episode 20. At each review, look at the signals that actually mean something early on, like how long people stay in an episode, which episodes get replies or shares, whether the right kind of people are reaching out, and which clips travel furthest. Then change one thing at a time so you can see what made the difference. If you have not launched yet, start with the podcast launch checklist so the first week is set up properly.
Is editing everything yourself one of the beginner mistakes?
To be very honest, editing your first few episodes yourself is not a mistake, it is one of the fastest ways to learn where you ramble and which questions land. The mistakes are in how beginners edit, right, either cutting every um and breath until the conversation sounds robotic and rushed, or leaving in a ten-minute tangent because they could not bear to cut it, and then doing all of it at 1 a.m. after a full day of work, which is when your judgement is worst. And if the show is a hobby, or you love the craft, keep going, because there is no business reason to hand it off.
If the show is meant to grow your business, though, the time matters more than the skill. Once you know how you want the show to sound, hand the edit to someone who listens to the whole episode and cuts for meaning, and spend those hours on guests, ideas and the clients the show brings in. Our Starter plan is $199 per episode with a human editor watching every minute and a first cut within 48 hours, and Studio is $299 for two to four cameras, all on our pricing. At the end of the day the show is there to grow you. So yeah. That's my way of saying it.
Fix these before episode 20
- Write one sentence that says who the show is for and what they walk away with, and test every topic against it.
- Open each episode on the strongest twenty or thirty seconds of the conversation instead of small talk.
- Record every speaker on their own dynamic mic and headphones, on separate tracks.
- Commit to one format and one release day for your first 20 episodes before changing anything.
- Title every episode around the idea or problem it covers, never only the number or the guest's name.
- Cut three or four captioned vertical clips from every episode and post them during release week.
- Review the show at episode 10 and episode 20 using retention and listener replies, not daily download counts.
Frequently asked questions
What is the most common mistake new podcasters make?
The most common mistake is starting without a clear listener in mind. When a show is about everything, nobody knows whether it is for them, guests feel random and titles come out vague. Writing one sentence about who the show serves and what they get from each episode fixes a surprising amount, because every topic, guest and title can then be checked against it.
How many episodes should I release at launch?
Launching with two or three episodes at once gives new listeners something to binge and shows them what the show is like beyond a single conversation. It also gives you a small head start before the weekly deadline kicks in. After launch, keep one or two finished episodes in reserve so a busy week never breaks your release schedule.
How long should I keep going before judging my podcast?
Give it at least 20 episodes on a steady schedule before making big decisions, because early numbers move slowly and say very little. Judge by whether the right people are showing up, replying, sharing or booking calls, and by how long listeners stay in each episode. If those signals are still flat at episode 20, change one thing at a time, starting with titles and the first minute.
Should I edit out every um and pause in my podcast?
No, cutting every filler word and breath makes a conversation sound robotic and rushed. A good edit removes long tangents, false starts, repeated points and dead air, and keeps the natural rhythm that makes listeners feel they are in the room. Listening to the whole episode first and then cutting for meaning rather than silence gives a far more natural result than an automatic filler remover.
Do I need video for my first podcast episodes?
You do not need video to start, but recording it from episode one gives you clips for YouTube, Instagram, TikTok and LinkedIn, which is often where new listeners first find a show. If video feels like too much, start with good audio habits, then add one camera once the format feels settled rather than switching style halfway through your first 20 episodes.
When should a beginner stop editing their own podcast?
Once the show has a business goal and editing starts pushing out client work, sleep or the release schedule, it is time to hand it off. Editing your first few episodes teaches you what a good edit looks like, which is useful. After that, our Starter plan at $199 per episode with a first cut within 48 hours lets you put those hours into guests and ideas instead.
Keep reading
Ready to stop editing your own podcast?
If you are a few episodes in and want a second pair of eyes on what to fix first, book a call with me, or check our pricing to see what an edit costs.