Guides

How to give feedback to your video editing agency so revisions stay fast

To keep revisions fast, send one consolidated list of notes from one decision-maker, put a timecode on every note, describe what you see and what you want instead, and mark which notes are must-fix and which are taste. Notes written like that can come back the next working day, while vague notes sent in pieces can stretch a single revision across a week. I see both kinds all the time, right, because we sit on the edit side of 200+ episodes a month across the shows we work on, and to be very honest the speed of a revision is decided far more by the note than by the editor.

1

free revision on Starter, so put every note into that one round

Unlimited

free revisions on Studio, still quickest when notes are batched

Next day

revisions come back the next working day after your notes arrive

8 to 12h

Dubai is ahead of the continental US, so evening notes start our day

What does a good revision note actually look like?

A good note answers where, what and why, in one or two lines. So instead of writing fix the names, you write at 14:32 the lower third says Jon, it should be John with an h. Instead of make it punchier, you write from 22:10 to 23:40 the car story drags, can we cut straight from the setup to the punchline. The editor can act on notes like those immediately, without guessing and without writing back to ask what you meant, and that writing back is where a lot of the lost days come from.

The why part sounds optional, right, but it is the piece that makes the next episode better. If you say cut the bit about the merger because it is not public yet, the editor now knows to watch for anything confidential in every future episode, and you never have to say it again. For instance, one line saying the guest's company name should never appear in a clip without their approval saves you a note on every single clip going forward. Basically, a note with a reason teaches the editor something for next time, and a note without one only fixes this one episode.

ONE EPISODE, A WEEK OF CLIPSHook first, captions burned in, reframed to 9:16. $25 each.

Why does one consolidated list matter so much?

Because every time a new note arrives after the editor has started, the work restarts. The editor reopens the project, makes the change, exports again and uploads again, and if another note arrives an hour later the same thing happens all over, so a revision that should take one working day turns into several, and nobody actually did anything wrong. Drip-fed notes feel faster to the person sending them, right, because you are reacting in real time, but on the other side they are much slower.

The second problem is people. If your co-host, your marketing person and your business partner each send notes separately, they will contradict each other at some point, one wants the intro longer and one wants it gone, and the editor is stuck choosing between people who all outrank them. So pick one decision-maker for each episode, let everyone send their thoughts to that person, and have that person send the editor one list. I know it sounds like extra admin, but at the end of the day it is the single change that speeds revisions up the most, does that make sense, right.

How do I separate fixes from matters of taste?

Split your list in two before you send it. Fixes are things that are objectively wrong, a misspelled name, the old sponsor read instead of the new one, a comment your guest asked to remove, audio that drops out for a few seconds. Taste is everything where you simply prefer something different, the music under the intro, how tight the pauses are, which angle we cut to during a laugh. Both are valid, but they get handled differently, because a fix is a quick change and a taste note sometimes needs a short conversation first.

This matters for your plan too, right. On Starter, which is $199 an episode, you get 1 free revision, so you want every note in that one round, fixes and taste together, clearly labelled. On Studio at $299 you get unlimited free revisions, and even then a clean split gets you a finished episode faster than several loose rounds would. Both plans are laid out on our pricing if you want to see what else is included. And if the same taste note keeps coming up episode after episode, tell us once and we will treat it as a rule rather than a revision.

UPLOAD TO INBOX, HOUR BY HOUR0hUpload6hSynced30hEdited48hIn your inboxRevisions come back the next working dayRecord Thursday, publish Monday, every week.

Should I leave comments in a review tool or send an email?

Whatever your agency uses, go for a tool where the comment sits on the exact frame, like Frame.io or a similar review link, because then the timecode is attached automatically and the editor can jump straight to it. An email with a list of timecodes works fine too, as long as every single note has one. What slows things down is the in-between stuff, a voice note that says somewhere around the middle, a screenshot with no time on it, or notes spread across a few different apps.

One small habit that helps a lot, right, is watching the whole cut once before writing anything at all. People who comment as they watch often write a note early on about something the editor already solved a couple of minutes later, or they ask for a change at the start that they would have changed their mind on by the end. So watch once for the feel, then go back and write the notes. If you want a structured way to look at a cut, our podcast editing checklist walks through what to check, from audio levels and names to sponsor reads and the ending.

How do I give fewer notes on every episode after the first?

The first episode with any new editor will always have the most notes, and that is completely fine, it is how they learn you. The trick is to turn those notes into a short brief so they never come up again, so name spellings for you and your regular guests, the words or topics you never want cut, how you like the intro to open, the sponsor reads and when they rotate, the look of your lower thirds and so on. Send it once and ask the agency to keep it on file for every episode.

When we take on a weekly show, this brief is the thing I push hardest on with our editors, right, because every episode is watched start to finish by a human editor, so they get to know how you speak, where you pause, which jokes land and which tangents can go. Over the first few episodes your notes should get shorter, because the editor starts making the calls you would have made yourself. If you publish every week, the weekly podcast editing service page goes into how that weekly rhythm works with us from the first episode onwards.

WHO IS STILL WATCHINGPunch-ins, pacing and on-screen text keep the frame alive.Shaped editRaw take

When should I send notes, given the time difference?

Timing is the easy win here. We are in Dubai, 8 to 12 hours ahead of the continental US, so anything you send in your evening is on an editor's desk at the start of our working day, and revisions come back the next working day. In practice the cleanest rhythm is to watch the first cut in your afternoon, gather everyone's thoughts, and send the single list that evening, so the editor starts on it fresh in the morning with nothing else in the way.

The catch here is sending notes in pieces across your day. The editor may start on the first piece, then the second piece arrives and changes something they already did, so part of the work gets done twice and the clock effectively resets. If you need a fix faster than the next working day, for instance because of a launch date you cannot move, say so in the very first line of the message and we will tell you honestly whether it can be done. I wrote more about how the overnight rhythm works in overnight video editing for US creators, right, if you want the actual timings.

When is a remote agency the wrong fit for how you give feedback?

Let me be very honest, some people give their clearest feedback sitting next to the editor, pointing at the screen and saying no, earlier, a bit earlier, there. If that is how you work and you want it every week, a remote team in another time zone will feel slow to you no matter how good the notes are, and a local editor in the room is worth the extra cost. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics puts the median pay for film and video editors at $75,420 a year, so you know roughly what that seat costs.

And if what you need is a one-off cinematic brand film where a director shapes it live in an edit suite, that is a production company's job, not ours. But if you are happy to watch a cut, write a clear list and get it back the next working day, the remote setup works really well, and honestly the discipline of written notes tends to make the show better over time, because every decision is written down and nothing depends on somebody remembering a conversation. I'm pretty sure that once you try it with one clean list, you will not want to go back to drip-feeding notes. So yeah. That's my way of saying it.

Before you hit send on revision notes

  • Watch the whole cut once without writing anything, then go back and take notes.
  • Put a timecode on every single note, or leave it as a comment on the exact frame.
  • Say what you see, what you want instead and why, in one or two lines.
  • Split the list into must-fix items and taste items so the editor can prioritise.
  • Collect everyone's thoughts first and send one list from one decision-maker.
  • Send it in your evening so it is waiting at the start of our working day.
  • Add any note you never want to repeat to the show brief for future episodes.

Frequently asked questions

How many revision rounds should I expect?

That depends on your plan and on your notes. Starter includes 1 free revision and Studio includes unlimited free revisions, and with a clear, consolidated list you should rarely need many rounds. If you keep needing several, look at the notes before you look at the editor, because the usual cause is feedback arriving in pieces or from several people at once.

Is it rude to give blunt feedback to an editor?

Not at all, as long as it is specific. Blunt and specific is far easier to act on than polite and vague, so saying this section is boring, cut it, beats saying maybe we could look at the pacing. Editors would much rather know exactly what you think the first time than discover it two rounds later, when the deadline is closer.

Can I send feedback as a voice note or a video?

You can, and some people explain taste much better out loud. Just say the timecode before each point, keep the recording to one episode, and send it as one recording rather than several. A short screen recording where you pause on the exact frame works well too, because the editor sees precisely what you are seeing when you talk.

What if my co-host and I disagree on the edit?

Settle it between you before the notes go out, because an editor cannot decide between two hosts. If you genuinely cannot agree on one section, ask for both versions of that section in the same revision and then pick one. That costs you one round instead of several, and it stops the disagreement spreading to every other note on the list.

Should I explain my style again on every episode?

No, write it down once. Put name spellings, sponsor reads, words you never want cut, your intro style and your graphics preferences into a short brief, and ask your agency to keep it on file. After that, your notes only need to cover what is specific to that one episode, which is exactly why they get shorter over time.

What is the fastest way to get an urgent fix?

Put the word urgent and your deadline in the first line, keep the request to the one change that matters, and include the timecode. A single clear fix is quick to turn around, while an urgent message that also carries a long list of taste notes slows everything down. If you know the deadline before recording, ask about the $75 rush 24-hour delivery.

Ready to stop editing your own podcast?

If you want edits that come back the next working day, see our pricing or book a call and I will walk you through exactly how our revisions work.